Our Pies

Auntie Mame’s Popular Pies


Every fall, Auntie Mame’s kitchen is packed to the rafters with crunchy, local, fresh picked apples from McWhorter’s Orchard in Argyle, NY. These perfect pie apples are baked into the best tasting apple pie you’ve ever eaten!

“Auntie Mame’s apple pie transports me to a crisp, cozy upstate autumn afternoon filled with warm, happy memories.”   Richard

Strawberry Rhubarb:

Two perfectly matched summer flavors baked into a delicious pie that’s available all year long!  Described as sweet/tart perfection in one bite, this flaky pie is always a crowd pleaser. This signature pie features local strawberries from Ariel’s Farm in Gansevoort, NY.

“I love to get my strawberry rhubarb pies from the weekly farmer’s market.  I crave the sweet taste of summer on my plate!”  Ellen


Who doesn’t love fresh baked blueberry pie? Auntie Mame’s blueberry pie features big bursts of sweet blueberries in every delicious forkful!  From Ariel’s Farm – of course!

“Every year, an Auntie Mame’s blueberry pie is my son’s birthday cake!”  Renee

Mixed Berry:

Red, ripe strawberries, blackberries, plump local blueberries and tangy raspberries combine for a taste temptation that can’t be beat.  An Auntie Mame’s mixed berry pie makes berry lovers smile with each bountiful bite!

“My family LOVES Auntie Mame’s mixed berry pie! We order one for every holiday and every special family dinner.  Sooooooo good!”  Nancy


She cannot tell a lie – cherry pie fans say this signature pie is award winning! Auntie Mame’s secret recipe is not too sweet, but just the right balance of rich, tart “cherriness.”

“Auntie Mame’s cherry pie has spoiled me – this special taste treat is the only cherry pie I ever want to eat!”   James 

Holiday Orders

Auntie Mame’s holiday pies are legendary!  Holidays will end on a high note with the first bite of these signature desserts – Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter – any holiday.  Auntie Mame takes traditional holiday pies to the next level.  Your personal favorites are sure to be on the Holiday Pie Menu. 


Holiday Pie Menu 

Auntie Mame wants to ensure that every single pie she bakes is exactly what you like, and exactly what you ordered. Contact her well in advance of the holiday to begin the delicious conversation.  Don’t wait – make sure that Auntie Mame’s Pies have an annual place at your table.  Contact/Order


Custom Orders

Pie-fection is Auntie Mame’s motto.  If you want to order a custom pie for that special event or special person, you’ve come to the right place.  Auntie Mame loves baking up perfect pies to order.  She requests one week advance ordering but can often accommodate on a bit shorter notice.  Contact her today to begin the delicious conversation.  Contact/Order